Islamabad — The Supreme Court of Pakistan has ruled, by a 2-1 majority, that decrees of UAE local appellate courts are not automatically enforceable in Pakistan, laying down a key legal principle on the enforcement of foreign court judgments in the country.
Under Section 44-A of the Code of Civil Procedure, the court held, only decrees of foreign courts notified by the federal government as superior courts can be directly executed in Pakistan. A decree from any other foreign court cannot simply be enforced here; it must be pursued through a fresh suit in a Pakistani court.
The court allowed an appeal filed by Engineering Kinetics (Private) Limited and set aside the judgments of the Lahore High Court and the trial court, which had treated the foreign decree as directly executable in Pakistan.
The dispute concerned a decree of the Abu Dhabi Court of First Instance dated 17 June 2014 against Engineering Kinetics. The question before the Supreme Court was whether that decree, as affirmed by the Abu Dhabi Court of Appeal, could be executed directly in Pakistan under Section 44-A.
Under the federal government’s notification dated 6 March 2007, only the UAE Federal Court of Appeal was recognised as a superior court for the purposes of direct enforcement in Pakistan. The court held that the Abu Dhabi Court of Appeal is part of the local judicial system of Abu Dhabi and falls outside that notification, so its decrees require a fresh suit in Pakistan rather than direct execution.
The majority opinion was authored by Justice Munib Akhtar, who held that a local court of appeal cannot be treated as the UAE Federal Court of Appeal. Justice Muhammad Shafi Siddiqui, who heard the matter as referee judge, agreed with Justice Akhtar, forming the 2-1 majority.
The case had come before a two-member bench comprising Justice Munib Akhtar and Justice Irfan Saadat Khan. When the two judges differed, the matter was referred to a third judge as referee, and Justice Shafi Siddiqui concurred with Justice Akhtar’s view, producing the majority judgment.
Justice Irfan Saadat Khan dissented. In his dissenting opinion, he took the view that the trial court’s decree had merged into the appellate court’s decree, so the decree under enforcement should be treated as the appellate court’s decree. He also held that the UAE is a recognised reciprocating territory for Pakistan and that the appellate court’s decree could be enforced in Pakistan.
The judgment was announced in open court on 19 November 2026. The ruling clarifies the distinction between the federal and local courts of the UAE for the purposes of Section 44-A and settles an important question about how foreign judgments are treated by Pakistani courts, with direct consequences for businesses and litigants involved in cross-border disputes.

Leave a Reply