The Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) has expressed strong displeasure over Defence Minister Khawaja Asif’s remarks about party chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, with senior leader Senator Sherry Rehman saying the comments were “unacceptable” and that the minister had “crossed a red line”.
Rehman made the remarks in a post on X on Sunday, according to Dunya News, which reported that the PPP had formally taken exception to Asif’s statements about Bilawal and the party. She said Asif had crossed a red line by making statements about the PPP and its chairman.
PPP MNA Sharmila Faruqui also condemned what she called the “derogatory language” and “irresponsible remarks” about the PPP leadership. “Political differences are answered with arguments, not personal attacks,” she said, adding: “This is a red line for us.”
The reaction follows a series of posts by Asif on X in recent days. On 19 November, the defence minister shared two video clips of Bilawal — one from an earlier parliamentary speech and one from his address at the Karachi Press Club on 17 November — and wrote that he had expected the younger generation to be “better and more principled”, but had found them to be “masters of duplicity” who change colours.
A day later, on 20 November, Asif responded to Bilawal’s claim of being a stakeholder in the political system, describing him as “not just a stakeholder, perhaps the biggest beneficiary” and calling his position “rank opportunism”. Both remarks were made on X and were widely reported in the Pakistani media.
The exchange comes in the wake of Bilawal’s address at the Karachi Press Club on 17 November, in which he criticised government policies and proposals for new provinces. The remarks set off a public row between the PPP and the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), the two main partners in the ruling coalition.
The leadership of both parties has since moved to contain the disagreement. President Asif Ali Zardari met Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on 19 November, and the two leaders agreed to settle their differences through dialogue, according to reports of the meeting.
The PPP’s latest response, however, shows that the party remains unhappy with the tone of the defence minister’s remarks, even as its leadership has sought to keep the coalition intact. The party has drawn a clear line on personal remarks about its chairman, while the broader political debate over provincial matters continues.
Neither Asif nor the PML-N has issued a fresh response to Rehman’s statement so far. The episode underlines the strain within the coalition, where the PPP has repeatedly voiced reservations about government policies while remaining a partner in the ruling arrangement.

Leave a Reply