Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari has hit back at federal ministers who criticised his opposition to dividing Sindh, accusing the government of picking a fight with him for speaking the truth and daring it to hold the debate openly.
“It appears they have decided to pick a fight with me for speaking the truth. Their reaction shows they are unwilling to tolerate criticism,” Bilawal said on Wednesday night, responding to a series of statements by federal ministers earlier in the day, The News reported.
The PPP chairman questioned how ordinary citizens could expect the government to hear their voices if politicians were unwilling to listen to him. He said the debate over new provinces had been initiated without consulting ministers, the prime minister or other political stakeholders.
“If you have initiated this debate, dare to hold it openly. It cannot be conducted through your own selected people, with everyone else expected to agree or remain silent,” he said.
Ministers’ rebuttal
The federal ministers had strongly criticised Bilawal’s opposition to the proposed division of Sindh, arguing that creating smaller provinces was necessary for better governance and that public opinion should prevail.
Defence Minister Khawaja Asif stressed that no political system could be changed without public support, while Federal Minister for Health Mustafa Kamal described the creation of smaller provinces as inevitable, saying the country could not function effectively without them.
Other ministers, including Talal Chaudhry, also questioned Bilawal’s stance, pointing to the PPP’s position on dividing Punjab and arguing that democracy required effective governance rather than merely political speeches and constitutional arguments.
A warning, not a threat
Bilawal had warned at the Karachi Press Club on Tuesday that forcibly dividing Sindh could deepen social divisions and lead to bloodshed. He said on Wednesday that his earlier remarks were intended as a warning, not a threat, and that coercion could trigger unrest that would be difficult to contain.
He recalled the political situation in Sindh during the 1980s and 1990s, when attempts had been made to create divisions within the province, and said the threat remained.
Turning to constitutional reforms, Bilawal described the establishment of a constitutional court under the 27th Amendment as a historic achievement, saying he would not backtrack on the amendment. He clarified that he was not calling for the amendment or constitutional courts to be abolished.
Proposals for a reset
The PPP chairman said a political and democratic reset required restoring the opposition’s trust. He proposed returning reserved seats to the opposition, emphasising that this was a suggestion rather than a red line.
“If we want to make a start, this is where we can begin,” he said, adding that the PPP had supported the government even when those seats were not in its hands.
Bilawal questioned who had the authority to declare that the system had collapsed and decide that it needed a reset. “Does the PCB chairman have the authority to say that the system has collapsed?” he asked.
Referring to PTI founder Imran Khan, Bilawal asked whether he could not be considered a political prisoner, given that he was both a politician and an inmate. “I find it difficult to accept that every prime minister of this country is a thief. I want to see a day when someone becomes prime minister of Pakistan and does not end up in jail,” he added.
Despite his reservations about the government’s treatment of its coalition partners, Bilawal said he continued to support the government and wanted Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to succeed. He said the public’s main expectation of political leaders was that they resolve the country’s economic problems.

Leave a Reply