Sindh Minister Saeed Ghani has strongly rejected any division of Sindh, saying the province will have only one chief minister, one governor, one assembly and one cabinet. Speaking to the media outside the Sindh Assembly on Friday, he said the assembly was expected to pass a resolution opposing the creation of any new province in Sindh.
Ghani, the provincial labour minister and the PPP’s Karachi division president, said the PPP and other parties had repeatedly opposed the division of Sindh. He said the PPP held a two-thirds majority in the assembly and did not support any division. Administrative units such as divisions, districts and talukas could be discussed within the law, he said, but not used to create multiple chief ministers or separate provincial governments.
He criticised the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) and the Jamaat-e-Islami, accusing the latter of attempting to revive the politics of the former in Karachi. He also condemned calls for strikes and incidents of burning and violence as unacceptable. Any attempt to introduce another system under the name of administrative units would not be acceptable to the PPP, he said.
On the same day, the mayors of Sindh’s six divisional headquarters held a joint press conference at the Karachi Press Club rejecting proposals for new provinces. Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab, Sukkur Mayor and Sindh government spokesperson Arsalan Islam Sheikh, Hyderabad Mayor Kashif Shoro, Mirpurkhas Mayor Abdul Rauf Ghori, Larkana Mayor Anwar Lohar and Shaheed Benazirabad Mayor Qazi Rasheed Bhatti said no compromise would be made on the province’s historical, cultural and geographical unity.
Arsalan Islam Sheikh said MQM-Pakistan convener Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui had misinterpreted Article 140-A of the Constitution and a Supreme Court judgment. Article 140-A concerned the empowerment of local governments, not the creation of new provinces, he said, while Article 239(4) set out the constitutional procedure for changing provincial boundaries and creating new provinces. A referendum could not replace that process, and any incorrect interpretation of the Constitution would be challenged through legal channels.
Arsalan said the PPP was not opposed in principle to new provinces, but such proposals should be considered where public needs remained unmet and the relevant assembly and people supported the change under the Constitution. He also called for consistent treatment of proposals concerning Punjab and Sindh. Murtaza Wahab said the mayors had gathered to promote love, unity and constitutional supremacy, urging leaders not to push Karachi back towards the fear of the 1980s and 1990s.
The debate follows PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari’s warning at the Karachi Press Club on Tuesday that forcibly dividing Sindh could revive ethnic tensions and violence. Bilawal said the PPP backed new provinces only through the Constitution and the law, and opposed any move imposed by force. Federal ministers, including Khawaja Asif, Mustafa Kamal and Attaullah Tarar, have argued that public opinion should be considered; Tarar’s referendum line on Friday repeated a position he had taken earlier in the week.
The MQM-Pakistan has opposed the Sindh Assembly move, with Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui describing a resolution against any new province as unconstitutional. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and President Asif Ali Zardari have meanwhile agreed to resolve the issues through dialogue, according to reports. For now, the PPP’s position, as stated by Ghani and the six mayors, is that Sindh’s unity is not negotiable.
