Rawalpindi police say they have completed the investigation into the murder of Hina Javed and forwarded the challan, or charge sheet, to the prosecution branch, naming domestic worker Zeeshan Arshad as the sole accused and clearing her husband, Dr Faisal Asghar, and her father-in-law of involvement in the killing, according to police sources.
Police said Section 376 of the Pakistan Penal Code, which relates to rape, had also been added to the case. The challan has been sent to the prosecution branch for legal scrutiny, police sources said.
Hina, a 45-year-old digital designer, was killed on 20 August at her home in Rawalpindi’s Lal Kurti area. Her body was found the next day in the bathroom, with her hands tied behind her back and a wire wrapped around her neck and tied to the shower. The case was registered at the Civil Lines police station on the complaint of her brother, Fahad Javed, who alleged that she had been subjected to violence before her death. The initial first information report had nominated her husband, her father-in-law and a domestic worker as suspects.
Police arrested both Faisal and Zeeshan in connection with the case, and a court later sent them to Adiala Jail on judicial remand. Hina’s father-in-law, Asghar Fayaz, was also named in the investigation, but police cleared him of suspicion and he was never arrested.
The forensic picture reported so far is more complicated. According to a summary of the DNA report cited by The News, the findings involve both Zeeshan and Faisal. The report said Faisal’s DNA matched at four locations and his fingerprints were found on the victim’s neck, her clothes, a door handle and a sheet, while Zeeshan’s DNA reportedly matched material found beneath Hina’s fingernails. The findings alone do not establish the guilt of either suspect.
The submission of the challan comes after the Rawalpindi District Prosecution Branch issued notices to the City Police Officer and the SSP Investigation over the charge sheet remaining pending for 86 days, although the law requires it within 14 days. The Additional District and Sessions Judge had also demanded its submission. The investigating officer said the case had gone through three inquiries, including one by the Crime Control Department and another by a parliamentary committee.
Hina’s family has disputed the police account. Her brother has said the family has no confidence in the investigation, alleging that evidence has been tampered with to benefit the husband, and has demanded a judicial commission for a transparent inquiry. The family had earlier approached the Punjab Ombudsman, seeking scrutiny of the DNA and polygraph test results, mobile phone call records, CCTV footage and other forensic evidence.
Zeeshan’s father, Muhammad Arshad, has also claimed his son is innocent and is being framed as the main accused. He said Zeeshan had worked at Hina’s house for seven months, had no previous criminal case against him, and alleged that police pressured his son to confess during remand. A Punjab Crime Control Department team led by Additional Inspector General Sohail Zafar Chattha is conducting a fresh review of the case. The allegations against all the accused remain to be determined through due process, and no one has been convicted in the case.


