Tag: fake invoices

  • FTO Uncovers Fake Invoice Sales Tax Fraud

    FTO Uncovers Fake Invoice Sales Tax Fraud

    The Federal Tax Ombudsman (FTO) Zafar Hijazi has uncovered a multimillion-rupee sales tax fraud in which hackers broke into a taxpayer’s Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) IRIS account and filed fake sales tax returns, exposing serious weaknesses in the country’s tax registration and digital security systems.

    According to the FTO’s ruling, the fraudsters filed fake returns for two consecutive tax periods, declaring supplies for which no actual business transactions had taken place. The bogus transactions also used up the complainant’s input tax credit accumulated from previous periods, leaving the taxpayer to bear the loss.

    The investigation found that virtual private network (VPN) connections were used to carry out the fraud, and the recorded internet protocol (IP) addresses were traced to Indonesia and the United Arab Emirates. However, the FTO said the available technical evidence could not conclusively identify the actual perpetrators behind the scheme.

    The ruling also revealed that transactions claimed to involve the Ministry of Defence and the Sindh Health Department did not exist in the records of either department. A newly established private limited company emerged as the main beneficiary of the fake transactions, which were worth millions of rupees.

    The company had obtained sales tax registration just one day after registering with the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP), without any effective verification of its business viability or supporting documents. It had uploaded the same document to meet different registration requirements, and the automated system accepted it. The FTO noted that the same company had also been identified as a beneficiary in another fake invoice case.

    Systemic weaknesses exposed

    Highlighting the regulatory gaps behind the fraud, the ombudsman said Rule 5 of the Sales Tax Rules, 2006, did not effectively cover all corporate entities. The ruling also identified the absence of timely data synchronisation between the FBR and the SECP as a major weakness in the registration and verification process.

    Nationwide crackdown ordered

    The FTO directed the FBR to launch a criminal investigation under Section 37A read with Section 2(37) of the Sales Tax Act, 1990, and to take legal action against the beneficiaries of the fake invoice scheme, including suspension of sales tax registrations, blacklisting of the entities involved and recovery of the tax under Section 11E of the Sales Tax Act, 1990, and Sales Tax General Order No. 12 of 2023.

    The ombudsman further ordered a nationwide review of companies involved in fake invoicing over the past year, and directed that a committee be formed to propose amendments to Rule 5 of the Sales Tax Rules, 2006. To prevent similar fraud, the authorities were told to introduce mandatory verification within 30 days of registration and quarterly scrutiny of newly registered companies.

    Pakistan Revenue Automation Limited (PRAL) was directed to strengthen the security of the FBR’s IRIS portal by introducing multi-factor authentication, biometric verification and automated IP monitoring to flag suspicious tax returns. The Commissioner Inland Revenue was also asked to consider restoring the complainant’s input tax credit, and all the bodies concerned were directed to implement the orders and submit a progress report within 60 days.